5 Tricky Situations for a Church Staff... And How to Navigate Them

In any organization, team, or family, conflict is inevitable. While some of us may be uncomfortable with disagreement or tension over a specific matter, conflict can actually be healthy…yes, even in a church!

In the following article, we’ll look at some common tricky situations and provide guidance on how to handle them, including examples of how to communicate effectively through email.

5 Conflicts on a Church Staff + How to Navigate Them [with example emails]

1. Scheduling Conflicts

Situation: Two groups want to use the same space at the same time.

Solution: Prioritize based on church policy and fairness. Communicate clearly and empathetically.

Email Example:

Subject: Resolving Schedule Conflict for Church Hall Usage

Dear [Group Leaders],

I hope this message finds you well. I understand there has been a scheduling conflict regarding the use of the church hall on [Date]. As much as we want to accommodate everyone, we have to adhere to our policy of 'first-come, first-served.' [First Group] made their request earlier, so we will have to honor their reservation.

However, we value [Second Group's] activities greatly. I would be happy to assist in finding an alternative time or space for your event. Let’s work together to find a suitable solution.

Best regards,

[Your Name]

Church Administrator

2. Resource Allocation Disputes

Situation: Two departments argue over limited resources.

Solution: Mediate a fair distribution based on needs and priorities.

Email Example:

Subject: Coordination for Fair Resource Allocation

Dear [Department Heads],

I’ve noticed some concerns regarding the allocation of [Resource]. It’s crucial that we share our resources in a way that supports all our ministries effectively. 

Could we arrange a meeting to discuss everyone’s needs and how we can equitably distribute what we have? Your cooperation and understanding are greatly appreciated.

Kind regards,

[Your Name]

Church Administrator

3. Personality Clashes

Situation: Two staff members have ongoing personal conflicts.

Solution: Facilitate a discussion to address the issue and find common ground.

Email Example:

Subject: Invitation to Conflict Resolution Meeting

Dear [Staff Members],

I’ve been made aware of some ongoing tension between you two. It's important for our church community that we work together harmoniously.

 I would like to invite you both to a meeting with me to openly discuss these issues and find a way forward. Your willingness to resolve this matter and work collaboratively will be beneficial to everyone involved!

Looking forward to meeting you both,

[Your Name]

Church Administrator

4. Communication Breakdowns

Situation: Misinformation or lack of communication causing confusion.

Solution: Establish clear communication channels and ensure all parties are informed.

Email Example:

Subject: Clarification and Improvement of Communication Channels

Dear [Staff Members],

It has come to my attention that there has been some confusion regarding [Issue]. To avoid such situations in the future, I propose we set up a more structured communication channel. This could involve regular meetings or a shared digital platform for updates. Your suggestions on how to improve our communication are welcome.

Thank you for your cooperation,

[Your Name]

Church Administrator

Easy-to-use Church Management Software

Start using powerful, yet intuitive, church management software that's been designed to help you save time, reduce frustration, and accomplish your church's goals.

Start a Free Trial of Breeze

5. Handling Feedback or Criticism

Situation: A staff member is upset about feedback or criticism they received from another team member or churchgoer.

Solution: Acknowledge their feelings, provide a space for open dialogue, and guide towards constructive resolution.

Email Example:

Subject: Addressing Your Concerns Regarding Recent Feedback

Dear [Staff Member’s Name],

I understand that you have some concerns regarding the feedback you received from [Source of Feedback]. I want to acknowledge your feelings on this matter—it’s important that everyone feels respected and supported in our community. I believe that open dialogue can often lead us to better understanding and improvement.

Would you be available for a meeting to discuss this further? It would be beneficial to explore how we can use this feedback constructively and address any misunderstandings. Please know that your perspective is valued, and I am here to support you through this process.

Looking forward to hearing from you,

[Your Name]

Church Administrator

Final Word: Conflict is Healthy

Remember: conflict healthy!

When managed well, conflict fosters an environment of open dialogue and critical thinking. It also prompts individuals and groups to challenge their assumptions, leading to innovative solutions and personal growth. 

Finally, conflict also strengthens relationships and team dynamics, as it requires communication, empathy, and understanding to reach a resolution. 

So take heart: Conflict is a pathway to growth, and can ultimately result in a more resilient church!