How and Why to Do Performance Reviews with Your Church Staff
I know, I know...performance reviews have sort of a bad rap.
Most people don’t love giving or receiving anything close to negative feedback.
Here’s the thing: If you’re not regularly and systematically evaluating the job performance of your staff, you are doing them and your church a major disservice!
Ok, so maybe you’re starting to buy-in or maybe you already do, but you struggle with the “how.”
Here are a few suggestions on how to implement a solid performance evaluation system.
First, start with clear job descriptions for all your employees.
And if you’re offended because you’re a church.
Call it a ministry description.
Anyway, in your ministry description there are three areas that need to be crystal clear:
These are all important because they are exactly what you will be evaluating. In order to fairly and consistently evaluate there must be clarity around what you are requiring.
A ministry description should be as detailed as necessary to provide clarity.
We go as far as to assign time percentages to each area of work.
For example, my own ministry description says something like 40% of my time is to be allocated to leading the student ministry department, 30% of my time is to be allocated to preaching...you get the idea.
If you’re wondering about the values—I’m talking about your organizational culture.
It’s important that this is very clear and that each employee understands that they are to model the values.
If you’re curious, here are our values:
Hospitality: Making those on the outside feel like they are part of the inside.
Relationships: Making connections that help people move toward Christ.
Integrity: Doing what we say and saying what we do.
Clarity: Value simple structures and clear communication.
Generosity: Sacrificially investing in the well-being of others.
If you don’t have clarity around your values, I highly suggest scheduling an off-site for your key leaders and defining your organizational values.
A key component to performance evaluations is regular one-on-one meetings between employees and supervisors.
In my opinion, these should be an hour long meeting every week or at least every other week.
The purpose of these meetings should be building relationships, problem solving, development and feedback—both positive and negative.
I believe that “Here’s something great that you did” and “Here’s an opportunity for growth” conversations should happen NOT in an annual review but every week.
Also, included in this one-on-one meeting, the supervisor should ask, “What can I do better?”
Open conversations about performance should be a regular thing.
If it happens all the time, it becomes normal and regular feedback is much clearer and easier to receive than negative feedback from that one time a few months ago.
If you’re a supervisor and you’re feeling nervous about this, let me put your mind at ease.
If your employee knows you are for them, you can say just about anything to them.
The key is that you MUST be truly and clearly for them and their development.
When you are clear about this, it is much easier to come alongside and say something like, “Let me show you something that I think is holding you back from your potential.”
Rather than, “Here’s something you are doing wrong and you better fix it or else.”
If you are a supervisor, first and foremost, be for your people and the rest will fall into place.
Maybe it’s your practice to conduct annual reviews.
This is fine, but I think semi-annual reviews are better because, again, more regular feedback is better.
So, how do you conduct a great review?
First, use the expectations, values and goals in the job description as a template for the review.
For example, in our review system, I receive a rating for each of our 5 organizational values, the expectations of my role and the goals that have been assigned to me.
That’s basically it.
If you want to provide additional clarity, you can also do something like Start, Stop and Continue.
In other words, stop doing this, start doing this and continue doing this.
It can be a good system for providing clear feedback.
Another important component of a good review is that there are NO SURPRISES.
There can be nothing new on a review.
That just isn’t cool!
The employee deserves to know if there are concerns or issues before they receive a review that will live in their permanent record.
If you haven’t been conducting performance evaluations, I hope you’re convinced.
I believe they are an important component of a healthy evaluation system.
Of course, it is very possible that your system is fantastic and way better than mine.
Perhaps you have some helpful information to share.
We’d love to hear your ideas or any questions you have in the comments below. Thanks for reading.
Get updates on tips for church management, happenings at Breeze, free resources for your church and more.
Breeze has been incredible. Their customer service, commitment to innovation, and their product are top-notch. I love the features, the ease of use and the mobile applications.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
All of our database needs have been more than met, it's easier to use than the last database we had, and the price is amazing - what a value this has been to our church! All of our staff can use this software and they do regularly. We use it to track…literally anything a church could possibly need to track regarding it's attenders.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
Breeze has been a great asset to our church and congregation. Especially from an administrative standpoint, it has been the most adaptable and easiest church database I have ever used. The features from blast emails to giving on-line, and texting have been one of our greatest assets. Thank you!Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
We switched from a major, web-based ChMS to Breeze and our decision is confirmed every day. We are a medium size church and we use Breeze for contributions, member management, event checkin and a few other applications custom to our church. I had trouble getting any staff to use our previous ChMS but almost all staff are using Breeze. The product is very well designed, extremely easy to learn and use and customer service is incredible.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
Breeze has opened the communication highway for our congregation and staff, with very little training. Because members can update their own records and search easily for other members - and map their locations, send emails and text right from Breeze, they love it and our data is more real-time accurate. Our ministries are stronger, because they can trust the data in Breeze, which is easily accessed anywhere, anytime.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
Breeze is the first ChMS my volunteers have actually embraced. That's because it's so easy to use. The software is very flexible and gives us the opportunity to make decisions based on actual data we've collected and not just hunches or stories we believe to be true.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
I cannot say enough about Breeze. Their customer service is so friendly, you feel like you have friends and family helping you get started, they're prompt to reply and will do whatever they can to help you get things sorted out. It's been so easy to learn, our staff is loving it and best of all even our staff who are not computer savvy find it a breeze (pun intended). We are just thrilled by our choice.Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!
From the start of our process looking for an online solution, Breeze has exceeded all our expectations. Fast data import, fast and friendly customer support, and we can’t say enough about how much we like the program itself. Very well designed and user friendly. On a scale of 1-10, Breeze gets a 15 from us!Try a demo of Breeze for yourself!